LordAsylus 2012-03-08 02:48:24

looks cool

SpamClamberton 2012-03-08 04:05:42

Nice idea. It would've made for a much better presentation though if you just had someone talking, rather than forcing people to pause every second and squint.

Also for the first several paragraphs it basically sounded like you wanted to build ToonBoom (An industry-standard 2D animation program that works like Flash but designed more for animation). Then it becomes apparent what you're doing is really built for 3D. You should probably make that clear from the start, because as much as 2D and 3D are used together, they still are separate markets.

SpamClamberton 2012-03-08 21:26:35

Well, if the software is for both 2D and 3D, you should probably introduce it right at the start as "2D and 3D animation software". The first paragraph refers to it as 'animation software', and then the second paragraph you start talking about Flash and Anime Studio, as well as Maya and Blender. When I say separate markets I mean in regards to the animators who are gonna want this. Cos I personally have much more of a need for 2D software than 3D, so I was sitting here at first not sure whether this product was relevant to me at all. I know it sounds stupid of me, but it really is beneficial to have that summary at the start of an advertisement. If it told me right at the start it was for 2D, 3D, 2.5D, whatever, then I would've instantly known it'd be worthwhile to watch the whole thing.
Also all the stuff you said about how Flash got it right and how the Keyframe is the highest order, that's the same in Toonboom. Of course it's flawed, but it still is that Flash timeline setup in a proper (2D-2.5D) animation program. I'm not saying ToonBoom is better than what you're building, I'm saying because you didn't overtly say 3D at the beginning that's what I assumed you were describing.
Once you sit through the whole presentation I agree, it is abundantly clear what the software is for and what it will do. But to grab potential buyers (or downloaders seeing as this is free), you need a summary at the start so people know whether they should care or not, and THEN fill in the details.
Cool stuff like that Sonic animation, it'd be good to use that at the start too. It's very impressive to look at, and will make people want to stop and listen.

Don't take these as attacks, your software looks really cool, I'm genuinely interested, I'm probably gonna follow it's development and I'm definitely gonna download this. All my nitpicking so far has just been about the presentation, since I'm guessing you'll be doing more of those throughout the software's production.

TubeSocSamurai 2012-03-08 22:01:57

you're right ^^^this does look cool if i understood correctly this software closes the gap between 3d and 2d software and simplifies as well as enhances the animation process offered by flash i cannot wait to see more from "helix"

Blitzkrieg667 2012-03-09 16:42:05

That hypothetical animation was the best thing I've ever sen.

I can't wait till you release a version that we can actually animate with, even just basic stuff.

Good luck with this.